https://phescreening.blog.gov.uk/2016/09/06/new-breast-screening-guidance-enables-radiographers-to-get-involved-in-arbitration-of-images/

New breast screening guidance enables radiographers to get involved in arbitration of images

The NHS Breast Screening Programme has a history of helping skilful and ambitious radiographers progress in their careers.

This approach has given us capacity to:

  • have double reading of mammograms – all images are read by 2 trained film readers
  • extend the age range for screening from 50-64 to 50-70

Qualified radiographers can progress to consultant level. This means they can run screening assessment clinics and undertake the roles traditionally undertaken by radiologists within the programme.

Now, we are opening up another area of work – arbitration in screen reading – to radiographers who have the necessary skills and experience.

Mary Sinclair IMG_2111
All images are read by 2 trained film readers

All breast screening images are read by 2 trained film readers

Screening aims to detect breast cancer at an early stage before an abnormality can be found – and we find most cancers that are visible on a mammogram.

All images are read by 2 trained film readers. If both of them identify an abnormality on the mammogram then the woman is normally recalled to an assessment clinic for further tests to obtain a diagnosis.

Sometimes the 2 readers disagree on whether there is an abnormality and there are various ways of dealing with this.  Some services always recall a woman to clinic if just 1 of the readers thinks further tests are needed to rule out cancer. Other services have an arbitration process to decide whether to recall the woman for further tests or to invite her again for routine screening in 3 years’ time.  In some cases, 1 clinician has the ultimate say in this arbitration process while, in others, a group or panel of film readers decides on the case.  Both methods have been effective in detecting cancers and returning women without cancer to routine recall.

Following discussions, we have agreed that individual radiographers who possess the appropriate skills and experience can be involved in this arbitration process. This involvement can either be as individual arbitrators (third readers) or leading a panel of arbitrators.

This has the advantages of:

  • allowing services to operate more flexibly by permitting more qualified individuals to arbitrate cases
  • reducing bottlenecks in the system when screen reading is delayed due to lack of staff

The new guidance on who can arbitrate is now available on GOV.UK.

PHE Screening blogs

PHE Screening blogs provide up to date news from all NHS screening programmes – replacing our previously published newsletters.

You can register to receive updates direct to your inbox, so there’s no need to keep checking for new blogs.